ESCP Europe Business School
Login Signup          Sitemap

CMC Blog

Posted by Tom van Laer - @tvanlaer at 16:10 - 0 Comments

A response to Why Academic Papers Are A Terrible Discussion Forum

(http://rationalconspiracy.com/2012/06/20/why-academic-papers-are-a-terrible-discussion-forum/)

I agree academic papers aren't good for discussion with the "real" world, but why are books the logical alternative? How about blogs, Facebook posts, Tweets, and Wikipedia updates? Could we invent a system to value our academic contributions through those media? Can we adapt the peer-review system to accommodate these new possibilities to show scholar relevance to the world? Could we win prizes for online contributions?

Online is better for discussions and we should be able to come up with some kind of quality review. Question is how we get enough people to participate. This question about participation may be related to the questions about quality review above. At the moment, the incentives to publish papers are much greater than the incentives to participate in the public debate on marketing matters. In that sense, my snide remark above about winning a prize for commenting may not be a throwaway comment.

Basically, I'd predict that if participation in public debate is incentivised over paper publishing, participation increases, which will lead to greater scrutiny of contributions, which will lead to higher quality. However, I do not yet see how a clear quality review system can come from that... Is that perhaps where the Creativity Marketing Centre comes in?

 

Latest comments

There are no comments yet. Be the first to comment this post!

Comment

Captcha
Get Social & Share

Instagram

Latest from CMC Blog
Most active posts
How to Build a Billion Dollar App - 7 Comments
Posted by Creativity Marketing Centre @Creativitymktg
at 24/06/2015 7:49
Who's creative, who's not? - 3 Comments
Posted by Benjamin Voyer
at 09/11/2012 10:00
‘Growth hacking’, the new marketing trend in startups - 3 Comments
Posted by Vishal Kapadia - @vishkap
at 05/11/2012 15:10
The Vicious Spiral of Consumer Expectations of Creative Brands - 2 Comments
Posted by Benjamin Voyer
at 07/01/2013 12:45
Are retail stores dinosaurs? - 1 Comments
Posted by Minas Kastanakis
at 15/03/2013 10:37
Kristine de Valck, dry chicken, and paintball - 1 Comments
Posted by Tom van Laer - @tvanlaer
at 05/03/2013 16:18
Shakespeare was wrong - 1 Comments
Posted by Peter Stephenson-Wright
at 12/02/2013 13:50
How should companies respond to stories in social media? - 1 Comments
Posted by Tom van Laer - @tvanlaer
at 19/11/2012 11:50
Value as process - 1 Comments
Posted by Vlad Glaveanu
at 16/11/2012 11:31
Latest posts
12th Annual London Campus Careers Fair our biggest yet!
Posted by ESCP Europe Business School
at 06/10/2017 6:14
ESCP Europe Business School (London) shortlisted for UK Business School of the Year
Posted by ESCP Europe Business School
at 07/09/2017 11:08
L’Oréal & BigPicture2017 : Shape the Future of the Industry of Beauty
Posted by ESCP Europe Business School
at 12/05/2017 6:33
Latest comments
On How to Build a Billion Dollar App by Free FIle Hosting
Tags

Anything in here will be replaced on browsers that support the canvas element

Authors